I was having my usual fun at CW's blog on this topic and hey! This poke is good enough for a post at this watering hole!
Reuse, reduce, and recycle mah!
The issue is not leasehold or freehold.
Whether one treats our homes for speculation or not (not everyone is a panda or koala bear).
The crux is have we OVERPAID or not?
If someone wants to sell HDB 3 room with 10 years lease remaining for $50,000, anyone who can count with primary school math would grab immediately (provided eligible)!
Where to find rent in Singapore for HDB 3 room at below $500 per month!? Some more can lock in the rent for the next 10 year! There goes one inflation concern if one is always fretting about rising prices ;)
Rent and invest the rest? LOL!
Similarly, if one OVERPAID for a investment/rental freehold property - like those Japanese during their housing boom - we may have to pass the "under water" property to our children (maybe our grandchildren even!) to collect enough rent to breakeven one day... Rent as panadols?
I remember someone smart did say IMAGINATION is more imporrant than knowledge. I wonder if this is true on this topic ;)
P.S. temperament, I agree with you. Singaporeans have been "conditioned" to parrot buy is better than rent for our homes. And our collective experience has proven it (so far).
Can anyone show me who bought a HDB flat DIRECTLY from big daddy who lost money? Its like trying to find a unicorn...
Now show me someone who lost money buying HDB flat and I'll show you a "bei kambing" who overpaid buying from the HDB resale market. These "bei kambings" who can't count are the target audience for big daddy when they reminded everyone what's the meaning of 99 leasehold. Wink.
But in Hong Kong, at current property prices and rentals we can get, I would prefer to rent. Buying has become speculation; even its for our own stay.
On the China part, I'll have to respectfully disagree with you. I 100% believe you when you said you "think"... LOL!
Our mainland cousins are sweating more bullets than us!
Renew for lease extention that cost only $1 is one thing. Renew and pay up to 1/3 of current property valuation is another thing totally!
Most of the China residential leases are for 70 years. We are better off with our 99-year leases. 99.9999% (yes, its a poke) of us will not live long enough to face this problem. Its something for our children or whoever is lucky to get this hand-me-down for singles like me ;)