Have you ever wondered why our COE (Certificate of Entitlement) for vehicles is based on auction (code for who got money gets) while our HDB BTO (Build-To-Order) is based on balloting (code for lucky draw)?
What would happen if they were switched?
What's the "true" market price for our HDB BTOs?
Its the price for resale after the 5 years minimum occupation rule is up isn't it?
You know it; I know it.
Its a substantial subsidy from big daddy. Period.
Yet there are those every once in a while will pretend, pretend complain HDB makes "obscene" profits and there's no subsidy at all...
OK lor, let's change the HDB BTO balloting to the COE price auction model.
How?
Two groups of HDB buyers would be most happy!
1) That's those who got no luck.
Try and try, can never get a ballot number for their preferred location in mature estates.
Give up, choose those "ulu" brand new HDB estates. OK. got ballot but the number they got is way at the end of the queue. Which means you get to choose what others have "discarded"...
For those who are very picky (property is location, location, location, no?), no choice have to "capitulate" and buy resale.
Pay a lot more than your neighbours who got theirs direct from HDB, but hey, anything money can solve, its no longer a problem. Wink.
2) Then there's those sour grape "carrots" who aren't mobile, they'll be glad if HDB BTO has switched to the COE price auction model, there goes the 2 bites of the cherry windfall!
And here they are, worried sick what will happen to their HDB flats after 99 years....
They are like the proverbial dog who sits on a nail and whines and whines, when the problem is easily solved by moving their butts.
But no.
If I can't make money (by moving), then everyone should not too!
Now consider for a moment what will happen if we implement the HDB balloting system for our COEs?
First, we'll get the ridiculous situation where a billionaire will not get a brand new car if he's that unlucky? Never mind the COE now is "free" under the balloting scheme...
And people being people, once they spot a "lobang" (opportunity), everyone will start flipping cars!
You never wondered why 2nd hand used HDB flats would cost more than brand new virgin HDB flats?
So what's so surprising about 2nd hand cars costing more than brand new cars fresh from the showroom if we go the balloting route?
Still don't believe balloting is a lucky draw subsidy?
If everyone and anyone can afford a car, what will happen?
No need to look far.
Just look at the major cities in Asia.
We'll just switch from complaining cars in Singapore so bloody expensive to whining about why big daddy not doing anything to the maddening traffic jams we face everyday!!!???
Hello? They sleeping or what!? Earn so much some more!
Its heartening big daddy has many schemes to help the disadvantaged and those with few means to own their own HDB flats, never mind if its just a 2 room HDB flat. We need to start somewhere first.
That's perhaps why when interviewed by the media on the HK protest situation, big daddy pointed out its a housing problem. Wink.
And when we had the constant breakdowns in MRT and overcrowding in the buses and MRT, there's the 40/60 swing to the opposition, remember?
People can accept car ownership is not for anyone and everyone, provided we get the "promised" Swiss standard of living level of public transportation.
But to be reminded you are "cattle-class" whenever you go to work...
Ouch!